"Creep Saying"

So this was/is a much talked about topic amidst my group of friends, and story goes as follows:
We were all pretty drunk one night, and I'm not too sure if someone said "creep saying" or if I came up with it out of thin air, but I suddenly brought forth the question, "If I was to say 'creep saying,' would I say it the same way when I say 'what was that creep saying?' as to when I say 'that's a creep saying?'?" I don't think I've ever gotten more confused looks from my friends in my entire life.... I meant it as in "that saying is creepy" and "someone whos a creep is saying something"... if you catch my drift.

I continue to get made fun of to this day... and this happened like 3 months ago.